No problem! Sorry for the delay in my own reply, I didn't want to just comment with a 'yay' until I actually had some more substantive details worked out to toss around. (If you're not up for this anymore, that's cool too. Just let me know!)

Right now, Anya's in kind of a bad place - she's just found out she has a power, which is really messing with her head after years of emotional abuse for *not* having one, and the one person she would have confided in about it left the island.

So I think she's probably going to do something stupid and self-destructive mostly-on-accident, like trying to practice her power outside and get obsessive about it and not realize it's getting dark until too late, or getting into a fight with someone she shouldn't (NPC, probably, since she's also feeling besieged/guilty/resentful of all the people saying STAND UP AND FIGHT THE INJUSTICE). How BAMF do you want Watson to be? He could save her from something or find her afterward and INSIST on treating her. What kind of scenario would work best for him finding her? Anyway, these are my ideas. Feel free to ask/suggest anything, I'm just brainstorming here.